Magistrate withdraws from Akwa Ibom anti-open grazing case after controversy

A magistrate has recused himself from a significant anti-open-grazing case in Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria, following controversy over his handling of the proceedings. The case, which pits the Commissioner of Police against Abdullahi Yusuf, centers on allegations that cattle repeatedly invaded the farms of investigative journalist Ibanga Isine. This legal battle is seen as a crucial test for Akwa Ibom State's anti-open-grazing law.

Magistrate Godwin Edemekong of Magistrate Court 7 announced his withdrawal, citing the "abrasive and offensive nature of the nominal complainant" and the "public attention the matter had attracted." His recusal comes after media reports highlighted concerns about his courtroom conduct, including excluding the complainant while allowing the defendant and others to remain. This decision had drawn criticism from media and civil society groups.

“

I want to thank the magistrate for doing the honourable thing. This is because, as it were, I had lost confidence in him. I didn’t see him as capable of giving me a fair hearing and justice.

Ibanga Isine, the journalist and farmer, welcomed the magistrate's decision, stating he had "lost confidence in him" and did not believe he could receive a fair hearing. However, Isine refuted any suggestion of offensive behavior towards the court, detailing an incident where he was singled out to switch off his phone while others were not. He questioned the specific focus on him, only to be told the directive was for everyone.

Monday's proceedings also saw renewed restrictions on media access. Journalists were denied entry unless they presented official identification and permits from the chief judge, despite ongoing transparency concerns. This occurred even after the Nigeria Union of Journalists had previously demanded sanctions against the magistrate for barring reporters. Isine has formally petitioned the chief judge of Akwa Ibom, requesting further action.

“

I never at any point insulted or did anything against His Worship.