‘No more caving’: Poilievre urges against concessions in U.S. trade talks

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre is pressing Prime Minister Mark Carney to resist making concessions in ongoing trade negotiations with the United States. Poilievre argues that Canada has repeatedly yielded to American demands without securing reciprocal benefits.

In a letter addressed to Carney, Poilievre and Conservative critic Shuvaloy Majumdar highlighted instances where Canada allegedly backed down. These include the removal of a digital services tax, dropping retaliatory tariffs on most U.S. products under CUSMA, and a revenue-sharing agreement for the Gordie Howe bridge. The timing of this push is critical, as President Donald Trump's significant 50% tariffs are scheduled to be implemented in just 10 days.

Earlier this week, Carney stated that Ottawa was pursuing a "win-win deal" encompassing sectors like steel, aluminum, forestry, and automobiles. However, he acknowledged uncertainty about achieving all objectives before the August 19 deadline for the tariffs, stating, "we'll see." Canada and Mexico had previously sought to extend the CUSMA trade pact for 16 years, but the U.S. preferred annual reviews.

“

For the past year and a half, you have backed down to one American demand after another while getting nothing in return, with concession after concession.

Concerns have surfaced from various sectors and provinces regarding potential concessions. Issues such as supply management and the ban on U.S. alcohol in provincial stores have been identified as key sticking points. Trump's executive orders last month cited provincial boycotts of American alcohol, Canada's retaliatory tariffs on U.S. vehicles, and dairy import quotas under Canada's supply management system as justifications for the new tariffs.

Canadian dairy farmers have warned the government against any compromises affecting their sector, which is protected by the current supply management system. Prime Minister Carney has affirmed his government's "loyalty" to this system. Some provincial premiers have also indicated they will not yield on U.S. alcohol bans and have suggested retaliatory measures, including dollar-for-dollar tariffs and threats to withhold energy and critical mineral exports. Carney previously mentioned retaliation as a possibility but did not specify the full range of options.

“

we’ll see.