Recent hospital budget increases ‘not fiscally sustainable’, Minister for Health warns

Ireland's Minister for Health, Jennifer Carroll MacNeill, has cautioned that the state cannot sustainably continue increasing hospital budgets at the recent rate. In a letter to the Dáil Public Accounts Committee (PAC), she highlighted that over-recruitment of more than 900 staff by hospitals locally, without formal approval from the Health Service Executive or Department of Health, has led to significant unfunded pay costs.

“

While this investment reflects real growth in demand and rising costs, it is not fiscally sustainable to continue with funding increases of this scale.

This statement follows warnings from three major voluntary hospitals about a combined funding shortfall exceeding €120 million this year. While acknowledging pressures from increased demand, workforce challenges, and rising care costs, Carroll MacNeill provided context on hospital financial performance. She noted that between 2022 and 2026, voluntary hospital budgets increased by €1.1 billion (36 percent) overall, outpacing growth in community-based services.

“

The same pattern is evident in individua

"While this investment reflects real growth in demand and rising costs, it is not fiscally sustainable to continue with funding increases of this scale," the Minister stated. She emphasized that the medium-term challenge for the health service involves achieving better value and improved patient flow by shifting care to community and primary settings, rather than solely expanding hospital budgets.

“

Composite activity is a single measure that brings together the main types of hospital work – inpatient admissions, day-case treatments, outpatient appointments and emergency department attendances – and weights them to reflect how resource intensive they are.

Furthermore, the Minister pointed out that hospital output has not matched the rise in staffing levels. Data shows that for complex care facilities, staffing increased by 36 percent between 2019 and 2025, while composite activity, a measure of inpatient admissions, day-case treatments, outpatient appointments, and emergency department attendances, grew by only 10 percent. Carroll MacNeill asserted that improving productivity and throughput within existing resources is "central to financial sustainability."

“

Looked at this way, the data shows that growth in hospital output has not kept pace with growth in staffing.