SPIEGEL Games Canon: How could SPIEGEL forget Monkey Island?

A recent compilation by a SPIEGEL jury, aiming to identify the 50 best video games, has ignited a significant discussion and drawn criticism. The list, intended to celebrate the pinnacle of interactive entertainment, has apparently overlooked or excluded certain genres, leading to controversy among gamers and critics.

The article highlights a particular point of contention: the omission of the beloved adventure game series "Monkey Island." This exclusion has raised eyebrows, given the series' iconic status and influence within the gaming community. The question posed is not just about one game, but implies a broader debate about the jury's selection criteria and their understanding of gaming history and diversity.

Furthermore, the description suggests that the jury's focus may have been narrow, prompting questions about the inclusion of other significant genres such as strategy games, simulations, and Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO) games. The implication is that the list might not fully represent the vast landscape of video gaming, potentially alienating fans of these excluded categories.

The SPIEGEL jury's selection process, while an attempt to curate a definitive list, has evidently stirred debate, underscoring the subjective nature of ranking art forms and the passionate engagement of the gaming public with their favorite titles. The article serves as a starting point for a larger conversation about what constitutes the "best" in video games and how such lists are compiled.