Supreme Court rules: Workplace insults and abuse cost chef severance pay

Turkey's Supreme Court has issued a landmark ruling, denying severance pay to a head chef dismissed for verbally abusing a trainee and creating a hostile work environment. The court upheld the employer's decision to terminate the chef's contract for just cause, establishing a significant precedent.

The case involved a head chef, identified as K.H., who sued his employer for unfair dismissal, seeking severance and other payments. However, the employer argued that K.H. frequently swore at and insulted the trainee chef, M.K., and other staff, thereby disrupting workplace harmony. The employer contended that this behavior constituted just cause for termination.

The initial court sided with the employee, finding insufficient evidence from the employer. However, the Supreme Court's 9th Civil Chamber took a different view. It emphasized that an employee's harassment, swearing, disruption of work peace, and breach of loyalty obligations provide valid grounds for an employer to dismiss an employee without severance.

“

An employee's harassment, swearing, disruption of work peace, and breach of loyalty obligations provide valid grounds for an employer to dismiss an employee without severance.

The Supreme Court's decision detailed that evidence confirmed K.H. had yelled at the trainee chef M.K. over the smell of cleaning cloths, using severe profanity and threats. Despite the trainee having a doctor's note following eye surgery, K.H. allegedly insulted him publicly, calling him an "ox," "idiot," "stupid," and "useless."

The court further noted that K.H. exhibited aggressive behavior towards other staff, disrupting the work order with his profanity. This conduct, the court concluded, destroyed the trust relationship between the employer and employee, justifying the termination under Article 25 of the Labor Law. Consequently, the chef is not entitled to severance or notice pay.

“

ox, idiot, stupid, useless, do whatever you want