Taiwanese Media Personality Loses Defamation Suit Over Online Comments

Veteran media personality and TV commentator Yao Hui-chen has lost a defamation lawsuit against an internet user who criticized her online. Yao had sued a netizen, identified only as Mr. You, seeking 100,000 New Taiwan dollars in damages. She claimed that comments made on her Facebook page, calling her an "utterly disgusting media person" and other insults, caused her emotional distress and damaged her reputation. The lawsuit stemmed from an online debate in December 2023, where Yao argued with Wu Yi-hsuan, then a spokesperson for the Taiwan People's Party, about the party's perceived lack of grassroots engagement, using the analogy of "princesses and princes" versus "maids."

Yao alleged that Wu twisted her words, leading to a backlash from Taiwan People's Party supporters who then attacked her online. She argued that Mr. You's comments specifically targeted her as a woman, exacerbating societal disadvantages faced by females, and went beyond professional critique into personal insult. She contended that this constituted defamation and caused significant harm to her reputation among friends, family, and followers. The court, however, found that while the netizen's remarks were "sharp and harsh," they did not cross the line into "groundless slander." The court reasoned that readers could independently judge the content and that, as a public figure, Yao Hui-chen should anticipate a certain level of critical commentary.

Following the ruling, Yao Hui-chen posted on Facebook, expressing a sense of release. "The reason I couldn't sue successfully is because I am a public figure," she wrote. "Later, seeing the pathetic state of this group of 'grass' [a reference to the Taiwan People's Party's supporters], I felt relieved. No wonder you are 'grass.'" Her statement suggests a resignation to the outcome, linking her defeat partly to her status as a public figure and partly to her perception of the online critics' behavior, which she seems to view as characteristic of the group she clashed with.

“

The reason I couldn't sue successfully is because I am a public figure. Later, seeing the pathetic state of this group of 'grass,' I felt relieved. No wonder you are 'grass.'