Ten great films that almost no one saw and deserve a second chance

In a weekly dialogue, a film critic reveals a new passion: hunting for overlooked cinematic gems. The critic notes the overwhelming quantity of content available on streaming platforms, making it difficult to separate the wheat from the chaff. However, these ever-changing libraries also serve as museums, allowing for a re-evaluation of films that were either ignored or harshly criticized upon their release.

The critic confesses to changing opinions and finding merit where none was initially perceived. This personal journey leads to a curated list of ten "noble metal" films that previously met with indifference or varied criticism. The first film highlighted is "The Good Shepherd," described as approaching masterpiece status and demanding a concentrated, attentive gaze. This film, available on HBO Max, chronicles the birth of the CIA through the eyes of a prominent agent, played by Matt Damon.

"The Good Shepherd" is Robert De Niro's second directorial effort, and he also plays a small but significant role. The ensemble cast is lauded as spectacular, featuring Damon, Alec Baldwin, Michael Gambon, Angelina Jolie, Billy Crudup, and Eddie Redmayne. The film is not a typical spy thriller like James Bond; instead, it delves into the ruthless, chess-like maneuvering described by John le Carré, set within the context of American university lodges, class distinctions, and a near-religious patriotism. The film's title itself hints at a religious undertone, evident in its rituals, traditions, silences, and the invisible forces guiding the characters.

Contrary to expectations, "The Good Shepherd" is not a "denunciation" film, a fact that apparently frustrated critics upon its release over a decade ago. The film was not about condemning the CIA but was seen as ambiguous, focusing instead on personal drama and the profound human theme of transcending through vocation versus concentrating on the biological propagation of the species. This dilemma is presented to the protagonist when he encounters the "traitor" during the failed Bay of Pigs invasion, which opens the movie. The critic suggests there is much more to discuss, which is itself a high compliment.

Also available on HBO Max is "Miss Sloane," which, in a different tone, explores the chasm between professional vocation and private life. The article describes it as a political film devoid of ideological posturing and notes its success in the U.S., though it received less attention locally.