Tensions Rise Between Uruguay's Health Ministry and Mutual Associations Over System Reforms

A "frictioned" relationship characterizes the current dynamic between Uruguay's Ministry of Public Health (MSP) and the country's mutual health associations. This tension stems from proposed modifications to the national health system (SNIS), measures that have been approved, and unfulfilled "promises" regarding access to funds.

“

The relationship is a bit strained because all these articles have been opened up and the atmosphere is not the same. Instead of having the mutual associations as allies, today they are generating opposition because the actions taken are not viewed favorably

Mutual health sources have expressed dissatisfaction, stating that the current environment has shifted from one of alliance to opposition due to actions perceived negatively by the sector. A key point of contention is the fourth article of a proposed bill related to Casmu, the third-largest mutual association. This article, if passed, would require mutual associations seeking state guarantee funds to obtain the Executive Power's "no objection" for appointing board members, managers, and technical directors. Mutual associations deem this article "unconstitutional," arguing it violates freedom of association and enterprise and constitutes undue interference in private institutions.

“

unconstitutional

Another contentious article, Article 247 of the Public Accounts, proposes that healthcare providers can only charge for medications listed in the Therapeutic Drug Formulary (FTM) at the value of the moderate fees (tickets and orders) set by the Executive Power. Currently, some mutual associations charge higher prices for branded FTM drugs than for their generic equivalents, even if they share the same active ingredient. The government aims to prevent this practice, but mutual associations view the change as an "error." They believe it will reduce their revenue, as the sale of these drugs is a significant source of funding, and could potentially lead to price increases for consumers if pharmacies capture these sales without competition from mutual providers.

“

against

Further complicating the relationship are the recent additions to the Integral Health Care Plan (PIAS), a common basket of services for all SNIS providers, championed by Minister Cristina Lustemberg. While these additions aim to expand healthcare coverage, some mutual associations feel that each new mandated service places an additional financial burden on them. Despite these ongoing debates and "frictions," sources within the mutual sector suggest that the broader health system remains "stable," even as discussions continue regarding the financial challenges faced by Casmu.

“

interfering in private institutions