US luxury car buyers increasingly migrating to mainstream brands

American consumers are increasingly shifting away from luxury vehicle brands to purchase models from mainstream manufacturers, with SUVs being a particularly popular choice. This trend, largely fueled by price considerations, suggests a significant change in the automotive market, according to an analysis by J.D. Power.

The data for the first half of 2026 reveals a notable shift: 32% of owners who replaced a mid-size luxury SUV opted for a vehicle from a conventional brand. Among these, 11% chose another mid-size conventional SUV, and 6% selected a compact conventional SUV. The trend is even more pronounced among owners of luxury compact cars, with 42% transitioning to a mass-market brand. For owners of compact luxury SUVs, the figure stands at 30%.

This phenomenon is particularly significant as mid-size luxury SUVs represent the highest-selling luxury segment. J.D. Power suggests that this move doesn't mean buyers are sacrificing comfort or technology. Instead, they are finding these features increasingly available in conventional models without the premium price associated with luxury badges. In contrast, pickup trucks are not experiencing a similar migration, with only a small and stable percentage of luxury vehicle owners switching to large or mid-size pickups.

The propensity to leave luxury brands also varies by age and income. Older generations, like Baby Boomers, tend to remain in the luxury market, while younger generations, including Gen X, Millennials, and especially Gen Z, show a higher inclination to switch to conventional brands. Income also plays a crucial role; households earning less than $100,000 annually show a higher rate of switching to mainstream brands compared to those with higher incomes. This data underscores the growing sophistication of mainstream vehicles, diminishing the traditional exclusivity of luxury brands and making the luxury badge less of a deciding factor for many consumers.

“

The change does not imply that buyers are giving up comfort or technology, but rather that they are increasingly finding these features in conventional models, without having to pay the premium price traditionally associated with a luxury brand.