Were the Argentinians all gangsters except Messi?
Translated from German, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.
At a glance
- Argentinas national football team faced harsh criticism after losing the World Cup final.
- Some media outlets and individuals labeled the team as "criminals" or "thugs," with Lionel Messi as the sole exception.
- The article argues against this demonization, suggesting that criticism of a team's playing style should not equate to labeling them as criminals.
Following their loss in the World Cup final, Argentina's national football team has become the target of intense criticism, with some outlets and individuals resorting to labeling the players as "criminals" or "thugs." This harsh judgment, however, notably excludes star player Lionel Messi, who is often singled out as the only exception to the negative portrayal.
The narrative paints Argentina as the "new enemy" of world football. Critiques range from calling the team "rowdy" and "unfair" to outright accusations of criminal behavior. This intense demonization, the article suggests, goes beyond legitimate criticism of their playing style or perceived unsportsmanlike conduct.
Andreas Hagenauer, the author, questions this extreme characterization. He argues that not every tough football match constitutes a "football crime," nor does every resilient team consist of criminals. The piece posits that the criticism directed at Argentina has rapidly escalated into outright demonization, creating a distorted perception of the team.
The article contends that while criticism of a team's aggressive or hard-nosed approach is valid, it should not devolve into labeling players as criminals. It highlights the distinction between evaluating a team's performance and resorting to personal attacks or broad, negative generalizations. The piece implicitly calls for a more nuanced discussion, separating the game's outcomes and styles from accusations of criminality.
Originally published by Der Standard in German. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.