Why Agostina Was Killed: Anatomy of a Sexual Crime

The murder of 14-year-old Agostina in Argentina is presented as a tragic symptom of a nation in decay, where systemic failures across the state, politics, and justice system have left vulnerable individuals unprotected. The article argues that years of national decline, marked by escalating poverty and marginalization, have created an environment where such crimes can occur. It criticizes sensationalist media coverage that exploits tragedy for ratings, exposing a young victim to hyper-sexualization in a society ill-equipped to protect its youth.

“

All failed Agostina. The state, politics, Justice, and even her own parents who did not know how to protect her.

The narrative surrounding Agostina's death is framed as a crime of power, intertwined with drug trafficking, political influence, and impunity. The alleged perpetrator, Barrelier, was reportedly hired by a Peronist councilman in Córdoba, suggesting a potential exchange of favors where political factions utilize individuals with criminal ties. There are also unconfirmed reports that Barrelier may have facilitated young people for consumption within powerful circles, further implicating corrupt power structures.

“

The plot of this sexual crime, which is fundamentally a crime of power, has all the ingredients of a country in decomposition: narco, power, gangs, impunity, marginality, clientelism.

Judicial ineptitude is a central theme, with Agostina's mother having reported her daughter missing and identified Barrelier as the last person to see her alive. Despite this, he was not immediately detained, raising questions about impunity, incompetence, or negligence within the justice system. Barrelier, who had a prior record for abuse, was only captured days later, after the crime scene was allegedly cleaned twice. The article also questions the actions of the victim's father's lawyers, who appeared to defend the prosecutor in the case rather than aggressively pursue justice for their client.

“

Barrelier was hired at the Municipality of Córdoba by a now-former Peronist councilman, in a probable exchange of favors because the gangs also serve as private armies for politics for other purposes.

Referencing feminist anthropologist Rita Segato, the article explores the broader context of male violence as a potential symptom of men's eroding roles in society. Segato's controversial theories suggest that for some men, violence becomes a means to assert masculinity in the face of perceived societal shifts and weakening traditional male identities. This perspective adds a layer of socio-cultural analysis to the immediate tragedy, suggesting that individual acts of violence may be linked to larger societal anxieties and power dynamics.

“

And, again, the infinite ineptitude of Justice. Melisa, Agostina's mother, had reported her daughter's disappearance on Sunday, May 24, in the morning, and in the afternoon, she expanded her report mentioning Barrelier as the last person who had seen her alive. Why wasn't he arrested at that moment? Impunity, incompetence, neglect?