Women's weight loss should align with menstrual cycle, advises doctor

For women striving to lose weight, a common frustration is experiencing weight fluctuations and intense cravings, particularly around their menstrual cycle. Dr. Xiao Jie-jian, a weight management physician in Taiwan, argues that many standard weight loss recommendations are designed for male bodies and fail to account for the hormonal shifts women experience.

“

Many weight loss suggestions are designed based on 'male bodies.' Because men do not have a menstrual cycle, their hormones are flat all month, so they can go low-carb every day or fast at any time, and they will lose weight by following the plan. However, women are different; your body changes seasons every month, and you must consider the impact of the menstrual cycle on your body.

Dr. Xiao explains that weight gain before a period is often due to water retention caused by progesterone, not fat accumulation. He advises women not to panic or excessively restrict their diet during this phase. Instead, he recommends comparing weight from "after this period" to "after the last period" for a more accurate measure of progress. He also notes that the pre-menstrual desire for sweets is a physiological response to a drop in serotonin during the luteal phase, which increases the brain's demand for carbohydrates.

Forcing a low-carb diet or severe calorie restriction during this time can increase stress hormones and heighten the risk of binge eating. Dr. Xiao suggests a "moderate-carb diet" in the week leading up to menstruation, incorporating sources like sweet potatoes, brown rice, or white rice with meals to help stabilize mood and appetite. This approach acknowledges the body's natural needs rather than fighting against them.

“

Don't be overly self-critical because of the weight increase before your period and the desire to eat sweets; these are mostly normal physiological changes. Mastering different cyclical dietary strategies is more helpful for long-term maintenance of ideal body shape than blindly dieting.

The most effective window for aggressive fat loss, according to Dr. Xiao, is the follicular phase, from the end of menstruation until ovulation. During this time, women's insulin sensitivity is better, making their bodies more efficient at using carbohydrates for energy rather than storing them as fat. He recommends scheduling high-carb days around strength training sessions to aid muscle recovery and reducing carb intake on rest days, utilizing carb cycling for enhanced fat loss efficiency. By aligning dietary strategies with the menstrual cycle, women can improve their chances of successful and sustainable weight management.

“

The truly suitable time for aggressive fat loss is the follicular phase, from the end of menstruation to ovulation. During this time, women's insulin sensitivity is better, and their bodies are more likely to use carbohydrates as energy rather than storing them as fat.