AI, Write for Us! What Could Possibly Go Wrong?

The author laments the potential loss of human culture and identity as artificial intelligence increasingly encroaches on creative endeavors, particularly writing. He draws parallels to forgotten skills like darning socks or calculating sums, suggesting that while these were practical losses, the abandonment of writing to AI represents a more profound diminishment of what it means to be human.

“

If we stop writing down our own thoughts, we give up a cornerstone of our humanity.

The core of the argument rests on the definition of humans as rational and social animals, whose unique capacity for thought and community is intrinsically linked to language. Writing, the author contends, gives permanence, weight, and value to spoken words, but this is only meaningful if the words originate from the individual. The emotional response to discovering a friend or relative has used AI for personal messages, like birthday cards or wedding speeches, is presented as a valid indicator of this loss, even if the AI-generated content is technically superior.

“

How do you feel when you realize that a friend wrote her birthday card with ChatGPT? Or your uncle his wedding speech with Claude?

This erosion of authentic expression, the author suggests, undermines genuine human connection. The article implies that the convenience and efficiency offered by AI in writing come at the cost of a fundamental human trait, leading to a future where personal communication lacks the sincerity and individuality that define human relationships. The piece concludes with a stark warning: relinquishing writing to AI means surrendering a piece of our humanity.

“

You will be angry, rightly so. Even if the artificial result is objectively better, polished and flawless.