DistantNews
Support us
Amazonas Court of Justice faces scrutiny over inefficiency and 'balloon dispatch' practices
🇧🇷 Brazil /Crime & Justice

Amazonas Court of Justice faces scrutiny over inefficiency and 'balloon dispatch' practices

From Estadão · () Portuguese

Translated from Portuguese, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

News Documents & data Under investigation
  • An inspection of the Amazonas Court of Justice revealed widespread management inefficiency and data inconsistencies.
  • The inspection uncovered "harmful registry practices," including a "balloon dispatch" method that masks real processing times.
  • A national judicial oversight body has ordered an extraordinary review of five specific court units.

A routine inspection by the National Justice Corregidoria has uncovered a panorama of management inefficiency, data inconsistencies, and delays within at least five branches of the Amazonas Court of Justice. The findings point to an "accumulation of administrative irregularities."

accumulation of administrative irregularities

— National Justice CorregidoriaDescribing the findings of an inspection into the Amazonas Court of Justice.

According to the Corregidoria's report, a detailed examination of the affected units revealed a scenario where "ordinary oversight tools proved insufficient to restore normal procedural flow." The inspection identified the persistence of "harmful registry practices." One such practice, termed "despacho-balão" or "balloon dispatch," involves the double submission of case files for review through generic and purely formal entries. This artifice serves to mask the actual time cases remain stalled.

The situation is exacerbated by hundreds of disciplinary proceedings involving magistrates that are currently pending before the Corregidoria. The report notes that "this context of institutional fragility is directly reflected in the management of case archives."

ordinary oversight tools proved insufficient to restore normal procedural flow

— National Justice CorregidoriaDetailing the failure of standard procedures in addressing the issues at the Amazonas Court of Justice.

As a preliminary result of the investigation, based on data collected last October, National Justice Corregidoria Mauro Campbell Marques ordered an extraordinary review of five specific units within the Amazonas judiciary. These include the 2nd Public Treasury Court of Manaus, the 7th Civil and Labor Accidents Court, the 1st Tax and State Debt Court, the 4th Chamber of the Second Recursal Panel, and the 2nd Jury Court.

harmful registry practices

— National Justice CorregidoriaIdentifying problematic administrative procedures within the Amazonas Court of Justice.

The Corregidoria has directed the investigation to focus on the performance and output of judges Leoney Figliuolo Harraquian, Rosselberto Himenes, Marco Antônio Pinto da Costa, Sanã Nogueira Almendros de Oliveira, and Fábio Alfaia. The investigation team will have unrestricted access to all physical and virtual facilities of the Amazonas Court, with authorization to request and access any documents, records, or data deemed relevant to clarify the facts and determine functional and administrative responsibilities.

This context of institutional fragility is directly reflected in the management of case archives.

— National Justice CorregidoriaLinking the court's overall weakness to its handling of case files.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Estadão in Portuguese. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.

More Stories

From Our Blog