Attempt to revive the clinically dead peace process
Translated from Slovenian, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.
At a glance
- The author argues that the events in Gaza, southern Lebanon, and the West Bank do not constitute genocide, distinguishing them from historical events in Bosnia and the Holocaust.
- The piece asserts that Palestinians have contributed to their situation, citing their rejection of a two-state solution in 1948 and the actions of groups like Hamas.
- It criticizes the notion of Arab solidarity with Palestinians, pointing to Egypt's closure of its border with Gaza.
The author contends that the ongoing conflict in Gaza, southern Lebanon, and the West Bank, while causing suffering and destruction, does not meet the definition of genocide. The piece draws a stark contrast with historical events such as the genocide in Bosnia, where Bosnian Serb paramilitary units systematically killed Bosnian Muslims, and the Holocaust, during which Nazis murdered six million Jews.
"What Israel is doing is not genocide," the author states, highlighting that Israel warns Palestinians before bombing and even provides tents for evacuation. This is contrasted with the actions of Russian President Vladimir Putin in Ukraine, whom the author believes does not recognize the Ukrainian nation. While acknowledging the hardship and displacement, the author places significant blame on the Palestinians themselves.
The article asserts that Palestinians missed an opportunity for statehood in 1948 when a UN proposal offered two states. Instead, the author claims, they sought all of historic Palestine, disregarding Jewish presence and historical claims. Groups like Hamas are criticized for prioritizing the destruction of Israel over the well-being of Palestinians.
Furthermore, the piece questions the historical significance of Gaza for Israel, noting its return to Egypt after the Six-Day War and the subsequent forced relocation of Israeli settlers. The author also points to Egypt's complete closure of its border with Gaza during Israel's recent intervention as an example of limited Arab solidarity, concluding that Israel is often unfairly blamed for the situation.
What Israel is doing is not genocide
Originally published by Delo in Slovenian. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.