DistantNews
Support us
BN better off contesting Melaka polls solo if talks fail, says analyst
🇲🇾 Malaysia /Elections & Politics

BN better off contesting Melaka polls solo if talks fail, says analyst

From Utusan Malaysia · () Malay

Translated from Malay, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

News Named sources Context piece
  • A political science lecturer suggests Barisan Nasional (BN) should contest the Melaka state election solo if negotiations with Pakatan Harapan (PH) or Perikatan Nasional (PN) fail.
  • The lecturer proposes BN's 21-7 seat allocation formula as a critical point, noting PH's minimal gain and PN's potential role as a junior partner.
  • BN's strong performance in the Johor state election and its status as the incumbent government bolster the argument for contesting independently.

Barisan Nasional (BN) might be better off contesting the upcoming Melaka state election alone if coalition talks with Pakatan Harapan (PH) or Perikatan Nasional (PN) falter, according to a senior lecturer at Universiti Malaya.

BN has already set its stance to defend 21 state seats, while the remaining seven can be used as a negotiation space with parties that have the potential to be cooperation partners.

— Dr. Mohammad Tawfik YaakubExplaining Barisan Nasional's proposed seat allocation strategy for the Melaka state election.

Dr. Mohammad Tawfik Yaakub proposed that BN has already set its stance to defend 21 state seats, leaving the remaining seven for negotiation. This 21-7 formula, he explained, would test how willing PH or PN are to accept BN's terms. For PH, seven seats would only add two to their 2021 wins, while for PN, it represents an increase but raises questions about their willingness to be a junior partner to BN.

If no agreement is reached, Tawfik believes BN has a "more reasonable" option to go solo, citing confidence from the Johor state election. In Johor, BN secured 48 out of 56 seats, demonstrating strong grassroots support and the ability to win significantly under its own banner. He questioned why BN would cede many seats if the Johor model proved BN's independent strength.

For PH, seven seats actually only add two from the five seats it won in 2021.

— Dr. Mohammad Tawfik YaakubAnalyzing the implications of the proposed seat distribution for Pakatan Harapan.

BN also holds advantages as the incumbent state government, possessing a strong UMNO grassroots organization and a Chief Minister who will lead the campaign. Tawfik noted that while a PH-PN alliance might seem mathematically easier for seat allocation, aiming to break BN's dominance, political realities often complicate such arithmetic.

For PN, seven seats are an increase of five compared to the two seats it won in 2021, but the question arises whether PN is willing to play the role of a 'junior partner' to BN.

— Dr. Mohammad Tawfik YaakubAssessing Perikatan Nasional's potential position in negotiations.

Such a collaboration between PH and PN might only become realistic if BN closes the door or imposes overly harsh terms, potentially leading them to consider a tactical alliance against BN. However, Tawfik anticipates this scenario is less likely than other electoral arrangements.

If no party agrees to the proposed seat distribution formula, BN has a more reasonable option to go solo.

— Dr. Mohammad Tawfik YaakubStating BN's alternative strategy if negotiations fail.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Utusan Malaysia in Malay. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.

More Stories

From Our Blog