Director of Public Prosecutions Criticizes Salary Cap Bill

The Icelandic judiciary, represented by the Director of Public Prosecutions, Sigríður J. Friðjónsdóttir, has voiced strong opposition to a proposed government bill that seeks to cap salary increases for elected officials and senior civil servants. This bill, which includes judges and prosecutors, aims to limit their annual raise to 3.5%, a stark contrast to the 9.7% increase dictated by the general wage index. This move has ignited concerns about the independence and integrity of the justice system.

“

It is inappropriate for the salaries of prosecutors and judges to be tied and dependent on the salaries of nationally elected representatives.

Sigríður J. Friðjónsdóttir unequivocally supports the criticism leveled by the Judges' Association of Iceland. She argues that it is inappropriate to tie the salaries of prosecutors and judges to those of elected representatives. The principle of separation of powers dictates that the judiciary should operate independently, free from undue political influence. Linking judicial and prosecutorial salaries to political decisions directly interferes with this fundamental principle, potentially compromising the impartiality required for fair judgment and prosecution.

Furthermore, the bill's mechanism of applying raises an average of a year after other state employees have received theirs is seen as a deliberate attempt to ensure that the raises for civil servants do not lead or exceed those of other state workers. However, for prosecutors, this 3.5% cap is viewed as a direct intervention in their compensation, undermining their professional standing. Kristbjörg Stephensen, chair of the Judges' Association, rightly points out that according to the European Convention on Human Rights, judges' salaries should not be subject to repeated political interference, a principle that clearly extends to prosecutors as well.

“

The decision that prosecutors' salaries shall only increase by 3.5% is direct interference with the salary conditions of the prosecution authority.

From our perspective in Iceland, this proposed legislation represents a concerning trend of political encroachment on the judiciary. The independence of our courts and prosecution service is a cornerstone of our democracy. Any attempt to control or influence their remuneration through political means, especially by tying it to the salaries of politicians, is a dangerous precedent. We believe that the salaries of judges and prosecutors must be determined based on objective criteria, ensuring they are commensurate with their responsibilities and insulated from political whims. This bill, if passed, would not only undermine the financial autonomy of the judiciary but also erode public trust in its impartiality.

“

According to the European Convention on Human Rights, judges' salaries should not be subject to repeated political interference.