Man convicted of trafficking Singaporean woman for sex work in Dubai

This report from CNA details a disturbing case of human trafficking that has reached a verdict in Singapore. Achraf Arjaouy, an Italian national, has been convicted of recruiting a Singaporean woman through deception for sexual exploitation in Dubai. The narrative, which began with a seemingly innocuous connection on Tinder, unraveled into a grim reality of exploitation, highlighting the insidious methods traffickers employ.

“

Objectively, that argument draws its strength from standing on top of a stereotype that real victims can be expected to behave or react in a certain way. Unfortunately... both history and experience have shown that the stereotype is thoroughly outdated and unreliable. The fact of the matter is that human beings react in a multitude of ways to any given situation.

Arjaouy's modus operandi involved a fabricated persona – a wealthy Qatari pilot seeking marriage. He preyed on the victim's aspirations, convincing her that she needed to provide US$10,000 as proof of funds for entry into Qatar. The shocking twist was his demand for sexual services in Dubai to raise this sum, with him collecting her earnings daily. The victim's eventual agreement, despite her revulsion, stemmed from a desperate belief that this was the only path to marriage. Her subsequent contraction of a sexually transmitted disease and eventual return to Singapore marked the end of her ordeal, though the psychological scars undoubtedly remain.

The court's rejection of Arjaouy's defense was particularly significant. His attempts to discredit the victim by questioning her credibility based on how a 'real victim' should behave, and by making objectable comments about her physical appearance in relation to sex work, were firmly rebuked by District Judge Eugene Teo. The judge's remarks serve as a powerful statement against harmful stereotypes, emphasizing that victims react in diverse ways and that attractiveness is subjective and not a prerequisite for exploitation. This legal stance is crucial in ensuring justice for victims who may not conform to preconceived notions.

“

Putting aside the objectionable nature of that argument for the moment, it is objectively an argument which draws its strength from standing on the proposition that only particular physical properties are capable of being attractive. Unfortunately... that proposition is also simply not true. We do not have to look far for an example. This case shows us that one does not have to be particularly tall, fair in complexion or even have a full head of hair to get by on one's looks.

From Singapore's perspective, this conviction underscores the nation's commitment to combating human trafficking. While the crime occurred in Dubai and the perpetrator is Italian, the legal proceedings took place here, reflecting Singapore's role as a regional hub and its zero-tolerance policy towards such heinous acts. The case also brings to light the vulnerabilities that can arise from online dating and the importance of vigilance. The mother's proactive engagement with the Singapore police when her daughter first went to Dubai was instrumental, demonstrating the critical role of family support and law enforcement cooperation in such sensitive cases.

“

The simple fact of the matter is humanity's diversity in taste runs very wide and there is no accounting for it and no universal standard of beauty.