Minister denies removal of Flávio Bolsonaro's AI-generated 'Top Gun' video

Brazil's Superior Electoral Court (TSE) minister André Mendonça has rejected a request to take down an AI-generated video featuring Flávio Bolsonaro, which mimics the style of the movie 'Top Gun'. The Federation Brasil da Esperança, a coalition including the PT, PV, and PCdoB parties, had filed a complaint seeking the video's removal and a fine against Bolsonaro.

The federation argued that the video, which depicts Flávio and Jair Bolsonaro piloting a military aircraft over the sea, falsely associates the Workers' Party (PT) with criminal organizations like the First Capital Command (PCC) and Red Command (CV). The video uses the iconic "Danger Zone" soundtrack from the 1986 film "Top Gun" and shows the virtual pilots destroying boats identified with the criminal factions, followed by a boat labeled "PT" fleeing the scene.

In his decision, Mendonça stated that political criticism is a fundamental aspect of democratic debate. He concluded that the video does not constitute a false imputation of crime against the PT. The minister emphasized that the Electoral Justice system should refrain from intervening in public discourse unless there is a clear dissemination of untrue facts.

“

The Electoral Justice must avoid interfering in the public debate, unless there is dissemination of untrue facts.

Bolsonaro's campaign had previously described the legal action as an attempt at "censorship," defending the video as a piece that "bothers those who do not care about national public security." The campaign also framed the video as part of their "Brazil Without Fear" plan.

The federation's lawyers contended that the video's depiction of a "Petista" boat with the same visual aesthetic and colors as the criminal factions constitutes an illicit attack on the Workers' Party's honor. They characterized the content as a "false, malicious, and deliberate linkage" to the country's two largest criminal organizations, deeming it a clear case of negative electoral propaganda based on defamation rather than ideological dissent.

“

political criticism is part of democratic debate and the video does not impute crime to the PT.