DistantNews
Support us
๐Ÿ‡ซ๐Ÿ‡ฏ Fiji /Elections & Politics

Sugar Minister yellow-carded

From FBC News · () English

Summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

At a glance

News Named sources Outcome reported
  • Fiji's Sugar Minister, Charan Jeath Singh, received a yellow card for disorderly conduct in Parliament.
  • The ruling followed heated exchanges with opposition MPs regarding budget allocations for multi-ethnic grants.
  • Both Singh and opposition MP Alvick Maharaj were found to have breached parliamentary rules.

Fiji's Sugar Minister, Charan Jeath Singh, has been issued a yellow card for disorderly conduct during a parliamentary session, marking a significant disciplinary action within the legislature. Speaker of Parliament Filimone Jitoko delivered the ruling after reviewing Hansard records and video footage of the incident.

listen to me

โ€” Charan Jeath SinghA phrase used by the Sugar Minister during a heated exchange, deemed unparliamentary by the Speaker.

The controversy stemmed from debates over a $2 million allocation for multi-ethnic grants to community-based organizations. During discussions on the 2025-2026 financial year budget, opposition MP Premila Kumar questioned the distribution and use of these funds. According to the Speaker, Minister Singh failed to provide a direct answer, instead referencing the previous government's actions and responding in a "very loud and aggressive tone" when prompted.

Singhโ€™s use of expressions including you listen to me and listen, โ€˜yarโ€™, particularly when delivered in what he considered a patronising and condescending manner, amounted to unparliamentary language.

โ€” Filimone JitokoThe Speaker of Parliament explaining the ruling against the Sugar Minister.

While Singh initially apologized after the Speaker's intervention, a second heated exchange occurred later with opposition MP Alvick Maharaj. Maharaj sought clarification on the same budget allocation and raised a separate issue concerning a crematorium upgrade. The Speaker recounted that Singh responded with what he described as a "diatribe about different religions and religious practices," accusing Maharaj of causing religious division.

Singh accused Maharaj of causing religious division in the country, while arguing that his ministry was working to promote social cohesion.

โ€” Filimone JitokoThe Speaker recounting Minister Singh's accusations against an opposition MP.

Maharaj reacted strongly to the accusation, leading to a point of order. Speaker Jitoko determined that Singh's use of phrases like "you listen to me" and "listen, โ€˜yarโ€™," delivered in a "patronizing and condescending manner," constituted unparliamentary language under Standing Order 75. Consequently, Singh was ordered to withdraw from Parliament for up to 90 minutes. Maharaj was also found guilty of disorderly conduct for his shouting response and was directed to submit a letter of apology to the Speaker.

Maharaj then exploded, shouting in objection to the accusation.

โ€” Filimone JitokoThe Speaker describing the opposition MP's reaction to the minister's remarks.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by FBC News. Summarized and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.