Uruguay doctors' mandatory service bill sparks internal party debate

A proposed law in Uruguay that would mandate service for newly graduated doctors is encountering significant resistance, not only from the opposition and medical sectors but also from within the ruling Frente Amplio party itself. The bill, introduced by Frente Amplio deputy Federico Preve, aims to address the shortage of medical specialists in rural areas.

“

The bill denaturalizes the concept of general interest by transforming it into an ineffective tool for solving a public management problem.

Frente Amplio deputy Luis Gallo expressed reservations about the initiative, despite agreeing that there is a "serious problem" with specialist access in the interior. Gallo, a pediatric surgeon himself, stated that the bill "denaturalizes the concept of general interest by transforming it into an ineffective tool for solving a public management problem." He argued that the mandatory service, as currently drafted, infringes on the "freedom of work" and could be considered "forced labor" according to the Ministry of Labor.

“

it is forced labor

The project stipulates that specialists and other professionals must work between four and 16 hours per week in public providers for two years. Failure to comply would result in the Ministry of Public Health not registering or habilitating their professional title for the duration of the non-compliance. Gallo called this penalty a "disproportion" between the offense and the sanction, questioning how doctors without habilitated titles would practice their specialty.

“

disproportion

Gallo proposed alternative solutions, suggesting that the state should use "economic and fiscal stimulus" to encourage professionals to work in remote areas naturally and with motivation. He also predicted that doctors would appeal such mandatory service requirements and likely win their legal challenges, deeming the project "inapplicable" for specialists.

“

economic and fiscal stimulus