Fintan O'Toole: Ireland’s governing philosophy is learned helplessness, and it’s getting worse

The Irish Times reports that Irish ministers are being advised to adopt a 'control spending' mantra as the nation navigates a period of international economic turbulence. While current forecasts indicate a healthy surplus for the public finances, the government faces pressure to curb departmental overspending. This cautionary approach is driven by concerns over rising inflation and the potential for sustained high oil prices stemming from the conflict in the Gulf.

“

Ministers will be warned today that tighter spending controls are required in their departments in order to stick within agreed budgets at a time of growing international threats to the Irish economy.

Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers is expected to emphasize the constraints that inflation will place on available resources later in the year, particularly if energy costs remain elevated. His department is already working to address an anticipated €600 million overspend in the Department of Education. The warning underscores the delicate balancing act the government must perform: fulfilling programme for government commitments while ensuring fiscal discipline.

“

inflation will constrain what resources can be made available later this year, particularly if high energy costs continue.

Minister for Finance Simon Harris has indicated that forecasts will be published to account for various scenarios, including the continuation of the Middle East war. The government is conscious of the need to provide immediate support to citizens facing economic hardship, as evidenced by recent intervention packages. However, as Taoiseach Micheál Martin stressed, 'fiscal sustainability' remains paramount. The strategy involves using available 'firepower' judiciously, ensuring the capacity to respond effectively to potential crises throughout the winter and to deliver a budget that advances government priorities while offering necessary assistance.

“

No, it would be foolish to rule anything out, quite frankly ... We’ve got to get the balance right – the balance between trying to help people in the here and now, because it’s tough for people ... but we’ve also got to make sure we have economic firepower to respond in the winter to deliver a good budget, a budget that can advance commitments in the programme for Government but also a budget that can help people if this crisis is continuing.