Indecent behaviour, indecent justice: How police misuse the law to arbitrarily detain citizens

The Kathmandu Post's investigation into the case of Safal Karki reveals a disturbing pattern of police misconduct and judicial overreach in Nepal. Karki's arbitrary detention and subsequent conviction on charges of "indecent behavior" highlight a systemic issue where laws are weaponized to suppress citizens who dare to question authority.

“

I live nearby. I’m on my way.

Our analysis of 220 cases from the Nepali calendar year 2082 BS shows a staggering 95 percent conviction rate for "indecent behavior." This statistic, coupled with the rampant use of "emergency arrest warrants"—a tool seemingly reserved for minor charges—points to a deliberate strategy of circumventing due process. The fact that witnesses cited in charge sheets differ from those in judgments, and that reporting officers often do not testify, underscores the lack of accountability within the system.

Legal experts confirm that courts frequently rubber-stamp pre-trial detention, effectively validating unlawful arrests rather than impartially assessing guilt. This practice, as seen in Karki's case where his statement was twisted into a confession, leaves citizens vulnerable and without recourse. The contrast in the use of emergency warrants for "indecent behavior" cases versus more serious offenses like human trafficking is stark, revealing a selective application of law enforcement powers.

“

found in suspicious circumstances and during questioning about drugs, he got into a dispute, used abusive words, and obstructed police work.

This situation is particularly concerning for Nepali citizens who may find themselves at the mercy of arbitrary detentions for minor infractions or perceived disrespect towards law enforcement. The Kathmandu Post remains committed to shedding light on these injustices and advocating for a legal system that upholds the rights and dignity of all individuals, rather than serving as a tool for arbitrary punishment.

“

I live nearby and I’m on the way