MUI Criticizes Jakarta's Catfish Disposal; Province Explores Charcoal Conversion

The Jakarta provincial government has launched a significant operation to tackle the invasive 'suckermouth catfish,' known locally as 'ikan sapu-sapu,' which are disrupting the city's aquatic ecosystems. These fish, notorious for their voracious appetite and rapid reproduction, have become a major concern for the health of Jakarta's rivers and waterways.

“

The provincial government of Jakarta is conducting a massive operation to capture suckermouth catfish.

However, the method employed for managing the captured fish has sparked controversy. The practice of burying the catfish alive has been strongly criticized by the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI). The MUI argues that this method inflicts unnecessary suffering on the animals and is therefore ethically problematic. This religious body's objection highlights a growing awareness and sensitivity towards animal welfare issues within Indonesia.

“

However, the burial of live suckermouth catfish by the Jakarta Provincial Government has been questioned by the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) as it causes unnecessary suffering.

In response to the criticism, Deputy Governor Rano Karno acknowledged that the scale of the catfish catch was surprising and that the current disposal method needs re-evaluation. The provincial government intends to consult with experts to determine the most appropriate and humane way to handle the invasive species. Furthermore, there is an expressed desire to find practical uses for the captured catfish. Citing an example from Brazil, where suckermouth catfish are reportedly processed into charcoal, Karno suggested exploring similar avenues for Jakarta. This innovative approach could potentially turn an ecological problem into a resource, demonstrating a commitment to finding sustainable solutions beyond simple eradication.

“

We were also surprised, you know. The amount of suckermouth catfish caught, several tons, we were surprised. Of course, we thought it would be only a little, I don't know the capacity perhaps.