DistantNews
Portuguese Author Valter Hugo Mãe Calls Harry Potter "Crap"
🇦🇷 Argentina /Culture & Society

Portuguese Author Valter Hugo Mãe Calls Harry Potter "Crap"

From La Nación · (20m ago) Spanish Critical tone

Translated from Spanish, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

TLDR

  • Portuguese writer Valter Hugo Mãe expressed a strong negative opinion about the Harry Potter series, calling it "crap."
  • Mãe, visiting the Book Fair in Buenos Aires, shared his views during an interview.
  • He also reflected on his Angolan childhood and its influence on his literary imagination.

Esteemed Portuguese author Valter Hugo Mãe, celebrated for his poetic prose and unique literary voice, has stirred conversation with a candid, albeit controversial, assessment of the globally beloved Harry Potter series. During his visit to the Buenos Aires Book Fair, Mãe did not mince words, dismissing the J.K. Rowling phenomenon as "crap" in an interview with LA NACION.

Harry Potter es una porquería

— Valter Hugo MãePortuguese writer Valter Hugo Mãe's strong negative opinion on the Harry Potter series during an interview.

Mãe, whose own works like 'The Machine of Making Spaniards' and 'Baltasar and Serapião' have garnered significant acclaim in Portugal and Brazil, including the prestigious José Saramago Prize, offered this sharp critique while discussing his literary influences and perspectives. His comments stand in stark contrast to the widespread adoration the Harry Potter books have received worldwide, highlighting a divergence in critical reception and artistic taste.

I think so. At two years old I was already in Portugal, but the Angolan imaginary remained as a literary construction in my head.

— Valter Hugo MãeMãe reflecting on how his Angolan origins influenced his literary imagination despite leaving at a young age.

Beyond his critique of popular fantasy literature, Mãe delved into the profound impact of his early life in Angola, a former Portuguese colony. Though he left at a young age, the Angolan landscape and the stories shared by his family forged a powerful literary imagination. He described his childhood memories of Angola as akin to a "magical kingdom," a fantastical realm that fueled his creative spirit, allowing him to invent a homeland that perhaps he never fully knew. This reflection on his origins underscores the deeply personal and imaginative wellsprings of his own writing, positioning his artistic vision as distinct from more conventional narratives.

Then I always say that everything that is said about Africa is fantasy, it is very magical.

— Valter Hugo MãeMãe discussing the fantastical and magical perception of Africa in literature and imagination.

The writer's willingness to voice such a strong, contrarian opinion on a cultural touchstone like Harry Potter, while also sharing intimate reflections on his formative experiences, showcases a fearless engagement with both popular culture and personal history. It is this blend of bold critique and introspective depth that defines Mãe's unique literary persona and invites readers to consider diverse perspectives on storytelling and its origins.

But I also remember because I was playing with a little boy who was very white, with very clear eyes. That I think I remember because the children with whom I played in Angola would be very different.

— Valter Hugo MãeMãe recalling a specific childhood memory from Angola that highlights cultural and physical differences.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by La Nación in Spanish. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.

More Stories

From Our Blog