Victorian Residents Fight 'Unfair' Land Tax Valuations Amidst Coastal Erosion Concerns

Residents of the low-lying community of Silverleaves on Phillip Island are locked in a battle with the State Revenue Office (SRO) over what they describe as grossly unfair land tax valuations. For years, these homeowners, many of whom are elderly or use their properties as holiday retreats, have been grappling with valuations that do not reflect the reality of their situation. Their land, situated in an area prone to coastal erosion and inundation, is subject to strict development restrictions, including a Melbourne Water flood overlay. This has led to instances where building permits are refused, as evidenced by a 2024 Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) decision. Despite these clear limitations, residents found their land values inflated, leading to higher rates bills. Ken Hailey's experience exemplifies the frustration: after his land value was initially slashed from $500,000 to $340,000, he fought to have it reduced further, eventually seeing it revised to $85,000 based on a High Court ruling concerning vacant land. However, the SRO's approach of only applying reduced valuations to those who formally object has sparked outrage. Residents feel the government is exploiting their lack of awareness or capacity to object, essentially imposing a 'tax grab' by collecting land tax on valuations they know to be incorrect. This situation, raised even in state parliament by Nationals MP Melina Bath, highlights a significant disconnect between government revenue targets and the lived realities of property owners facing environmental challenges and bureaucratic hurdles.

“

It seems ridiculous that the government is allowing for charges for land tax on properties when they know the figures are incorrect for the site values.