DistantNews
🇮🇩 Indonesia /Sports

Female Circumcision, Permissible? Muhammadiyah's Explanation

From Republika · (2d ago) Indonesian

Translated from Indonesian, summarized and contextualized by DistantNews.

TLDR

  • Muhammadiyah's Majelis Tarjih and Tajdid has issued a view on female circumcision, a practice found in many Muslim-majority countries.
  • The view distinguishes between male and female circumcision, noting that while male circumcision is generally considered obligatory for purity, female circumcision is not universally mandated and its purpose differs.
  • The article discusses a specific hadith related to female circumcision, noting that its authenticity is debated due to a weak chain of narrators and potential fabrication.

In Indonesia, the practice of circumcision, or 'khitan,' is widespread, particularly for boys, often signifying a transition to adulthood. However, the question of female circumcision ('sunat perempuan') has been a subject of discussion and varying interpretations within Islamic scholarship.

Muhammadiyah, a prominent Islamic organization in Indonesia, through its Majelis Tarjih and Tajdid, has offered its perspective on this issue. Their view, as detailed in the book 'Menafsir Ulang Kesehatan Reproduksi dalam Perspektif Islam Berkemajuan,' differentiates the purpose and obligation of circumcision for males and females.

While male circumcision is generally seen as essential for achieving purity and cleanliness, the organization notes that female circumcision is not considered obligatory in Islam by some scholars. The article references a hadith that suggests female circumcision should be moderate, aiming to 'brighten the face and please the husband.' However, the authenticity of this hadith is questioned due to a weak chain of narrators, with one narrator identified as having fabricated hadiths. This critical examination of religious texts is crucial for understanding Islamic practices in a modern context.

Sayatlah sedikit dan jangan berlebihan karena hal itu akan mencerahkan wajah dan menyenangkan suami

— Nabi Muhammad SAW (according to a hadith)This quote is presented as a directive regarding female circumcision, suggesting a purpose different from male circumcision, though its authenticity is debated.
DistantNews Editorial

Originally published by Republika in Indonesian. Translated, summarized, and contextualized by our editorial team with added local perspective. Read our editorial standards.