Importers Defend Pricing, Reject Direct Link to Dollar's Decline

ABC Color reports on a contentious debate unfolding in Paraguay regarding the relationship between currency fluctuations and consumer prices. Importers are pushing back against accusations that they are not passing on the benefits of a falling dollar to consumers, a claim largely spearheaded by the Paraguayan Chamber of Supermarkets (Capasu).

“

The supermarkets are 'price takers,' implying that the final price to the consumer depends on the cost set by suppliers (including importers).

The core of the importers' argument, as articulated by the Center for Importers of Paraguay (CIP), is that pricing is a complex mechanism. They emphasize that the dollar's exchange rate is just one variable among many. Factors such as regional inflation, the costs associated with suppliers, and the pervasive 'promotional dynamic'—where consumers expect and often only purchase discounted goods—significantly shape the final price on supermarket shelves.

“

There is no 'automatic transfer' of the dollar to the consumer, as it is not the only influencing variable.

This local perspective highlights a uniquely Paraguayan consumer culture deeply influenced by promotional sales. Importers, like CIP president Iván Dumot, point out that the expectation of constant discounts means that even when input costs decrease, retailers may be hesitant to lower prices unless they can maintain a promotional facade. The government, through the Ministry of Industry and Commerce (MIC), is attempting to mediate, proposing sustained, long-term discounts rather than short-term promotions. However, the current impasse, where supermarkets are reportedly unwilling to contribute to discounts, places the onus entirely on importers, fueling the ongoing dispute.

“

The Paraguayan consumer is accustomed to systems of offers, and if merchandise does not appear with a discount label on the shelves, the consumer does not acquire it.