Indonesian Health Alliance Urges Mandatory Warning Labels on Food Packaging

The push for clearer and more effective nutrition labeling in Indonesia is a critical public health issue, and the Aliansi Pangan Sehat (Healthy Food Alliance) is rightly bringing attention to the shortcomings of the current "Nutri Level" policy. As a publication deeply invested in the well-being of our citizens, we support the call for a more transparent and impactful approach to informing consumers about the nutritional content of their food.

The alliance's argument, backed by global research, that mandatory front-of-pack warning labels are superior to voluntary scoring systems like Nutri Level is compelling. The "health halo effect," where consumers mistakenly perceive products with moderate scores as entirely healthy and consume them excessively, is a genuine concern. This ambiguity can be particularly detrimental to vulnerable populations, including children, who may not have the nutritional literacy to discern the true implications of GGL content.

“

The Nutri Level system has the potential to create a health halo effect, where consumers perceive a product as healthier than it is, and then consume it excessively. This approach also does not provide enough nutritional information and protection for vulnerable groups such as children.

Furthermore, the alliance's critique of the policy-making process, highlighting a lack of meaningful public participation and transparency, is a serious matter. Decisions that directly impact public health and consumer choice should be developed through inclusive dialogue, involving civil society, individuals, and affected groups. The current approach, as described, risks creating policies that are not only less effective but also less accountable to the public they are intended to serve.

From our perspective, the Indonesian government must heed these calls for a review. Implementing a mandatory warning label system, characterized by clear visual cues and straightforward messaging, would empower consumers to make more informed decisions. This aligns with broader public health goals and ensures that nutritional information is accessible and understandable for everyone, fostering a healthier society.

“

The formulation process of the Nutri Level policy lacks transparency and did not meaningfully involve civil society, individuals, or affected groups.