Lenia Batres Wins Ruling Against IMPI; Court Annuls Denial of "Ministra del Pueblo" Trademark

In a significant victory for judicial independence and freedom of expression, Lenia Batres Guadarrama, a minister of Mexico's Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN), has successfully secured the right to use the trademark "Ministra del Pueblo." This resolution, announced via her social media channels, marks a triumph over the Mexican Institute of Industrial Property (IMPI), which had initially rejected her application. The Tribunal Federal de Justicia Administrativa (TFJA) has now declared IMPI's refusal null and void, affirming Batres's right to register the name she uses in her public activities. The IMPI's objection, based on the argument that "Ministra del Pueblo" might cause confusion with her official title, has been deemed unfounded by the TFJA's Specialized Chamber for Intellectual Property. This ruling underscores a critical point: the IMPI's decision was inconsistent and lacked thoroughness. The tribunal rightly pointed out that the IMPI has previously approved similar trademarks, including "Máynez Presidente de México" and "Yúnez Mi Senador," demonstrating a clear double standard in their application of trademark law. From Mexico's perspective, this case highlights the importance of protecting individual expression, even for high-ranking officials, and challenges bureaucratic overreach. It reaffirms that the public sphere should not unduly restrict the use of popular identifiers, especially when they do not inherently contravene public order or legal statutes. Minister Batres's persistence in pursuing this matter through the TFJA demonstrates a commitment to ensuring that legal processes are fair and that administrative bodies act congruently and exhaustively in their decisions. The ability to use "Ministra del Pueblo" allows her to maintain a connection with the populace, a connection that resonates deeply within the Mexican political landscape.

“

the TFJA's Specialized Chamber in Intellectual Property declared the nullity of the IMPI's resolution, by which the registration of the trademark had been denied.