Mother of Deceased Peñarol Fan Demands Progress in Investigation, Cites 'Investigative Deficit'

The mother of Juan Ignacio Suárez, a young Peñarol supporter who tragically died in May 2023, is demanding justice and urging for significant advancements in the investigation of her son's death. Her recent filing with the National Human Rights Institution (Inddhh) highlights a profound dissatisfaction with the pace and depth of the inquiry into what she describes as a 'homicide.'

“

the impulse of the investigation

Central to her complaint is the assertion of an 'investigative deficit,' a term she states has been explicitly acknowledged by the Prosecutor's Office itself. This admission, coupled with what she perceives as the Ministry of the Interior's 'institutional validation of police actions' without adequate internal review or disciplinary proceedings, fuels her call for greater accountability. The family, supported by Serpaj lawyers, maintains that police intervention directly led to Suárez becoming trapped in a fence and subsequently succumbing to his injuries.

“

investigative deficit expressly recognized by the intervening Prosecutor's Office

The incident, which occurred as Suárez attempted to bypass stadium security with contraband, escalated into a fatal confrontation. The forensic report, video evidence, and witness statements, according to the mother's filing, point to the police's actions as the 'efficient cause of death.' She details that the young man suffered fatal injuries from the fence's spikes, leading to hypovolemic shock and exsanguination.

“

institutional validation of police action

This case, as reported by El País, underscores a recurring tension in Uruguay between fan safety, stadium security protocols, and the conduct of law enforcement. The family's persistent pursuit of a thorough investigation, despite alleged institutional shortcomings, reflects a deep-seated desire for truth and justice. The narrative from their perspective is one of a young life lost due to what they believe was excessive force and a subsequent lack of transparency and diligence from the authorities responsible for investigating the matter. The international community might see this as a standard legal battle, but for Uruguay, it's a critical examination of police conduct and the justice system's responsiveness to citizens' grievances, especially in the charged atmosphere of football fandom.

“

the efficient cause of death was the police action that caused the young man to fall on the iron spikes of the access fence, suffering injuries that caused his death by hypovolemic shock and bleeding.