Poland: A Nation of Quick Action and Citizen Initiative, But Wary of the State

We Poles have always been known for our quick actions and bursts of energy, a trait that shone brightly when the war in Ukraine erupted. The sight of Polish mothers leaving strollers for Ukrainian families at the border in February 2022, and the half-million refugees finding shelter in private Polish homes, speaks volumes. This spontaneous outpouring of support, which some have termed a Polish 'humanitarian uprising,' highlights our innate ability to organize and adapt, a stark contrast to the more deliberative, long-term planning often seen in Germany. Our neighbors struggled to make swift decisions, while Poland was already supplying crucial weapons to Ukraine.

This national character of resourcefulness, of 'kombinować' (to scheme or figure things out), is deeply rooted in our history. Having lacked our own state for 123 years, and then enduring six years of brutal war from 1939, survival has always been paramount. The phrase 'kto handluje, ten żyje' (whoever trades, lives) from the war years encapsulates this spirit of pragmatic self-preservation. Yet, paradoxically, our greatest challenge has been learning to effectively manage our regained independence. This historical distrust of the state, once an oppressive foreign entity, lingers, making us hesitant to fully embrace its structures, even when they function well.

“

We are an adaptable and organized nation. Unlike our Western neighbors, when Germans cannot plan something – preferably years in advance – they cannot react quickly.

Our skepticism towards the state is further fueled by instances where official mechanisms falter, leaving citizens and their loved ones vulnerable. While we readily contribute to private collections, convincing Poles about the merits of progressive taxation to improve public services remains a hurdle. The energy seen in initiatives like 'Łatwogang' is undeniable, but channeling it effectively into strengthening public infrastructure is a persistent question. This deep-seated reliance on individual and community action, born from centuries of struggle, defines our unique approach to national challenges, often differing significantly from how other nations, particularly in the West, might rely more heavily on governmental solutions.

“

We have always had to resist foreign powers – Prussian, Austrian, and Russian. From 1939 onwards, for another six years, we had to improvise: 'There's a war now, whoever trades, lives.'