Reasonable Enforcement of Sidewalk Encroachments

Thanh Niên reports on the successful efforts by Ho Chi Minh City's police to restore order on sidewalks and roadways, nearly five months after launching a campaign against encroachments. The article highlights the substantial impact, with thousands of patrols leading to over 33,000 violation notices and nearly 29 billion VND in fines. Notably, about 70% of previously problematic areas have seen marked improvement, with spontaneous markets decreasing by 50%. Areas around hospitals and schools, often hotspots for sidewalk vendors and illegal parking, have also experienced significant reductions in encroachment. Trung tá Hồ Đức Thiện of the Police Department for Administrative Security emphasizes a 'humane and reasonable' approach, prioritizing warnings before issuing penalties. Thanh Niên frames this not just as an enforcement action but as part of a broader urban planning strategy. The newspaper features reader opinions, with many supporting the dual approach of strict enforcement coupled with practical solutions. One reader, Sơn Nguyễn Minh, expresses relief that the city is considering night markets and pedestrian streets as alternatives for street vendors, acknowledging how such policies have helped him escape poverty. Another perspective from Mai Hà points out that sidewalk vending is often a livelihood for the poor, distinct from established businesses that occupy prime spaces. The overarching sentiment in the coverage is that consistent, well-planned action is key to preventing the recurrence of sidewalk violations, a common frustration in Vietnam.

“

I am currently selling food on the sidewalk, and from a near-poor household, I have now escaped poverty, also thanks to humane policies. Now hearing that the authorities are reclaiming the sidewalks, but arranging us into night markets or pedestrian streets, I feel less anxious, hoping that such things will come true.